The Private Credit Bust Isn’t About the Next Lehman — It’s About the Credit Crunch That Follows
Everyone is watching for the next Lehman Brothers. That is the wrong thing to watch for.
The real danger unfolding right now in private credit — and increasingly in the global money markets that quietly underpin everything — is not a spectacular bank failure. It is a credit crunch (a broad tightening of the availability of loans and credit throughout the economy) that quietly strangles jobs, incomes, and growth for years after the headlines fade. That is the lesson of 2008 that almost nobody absorbed, and it is becoming urgently relevant again today.
An Indian Junk Bond Puts the Global Credit Cycle on Display
A recent news item from India crystallizes the problem. Shapoorji Pallonji, one of India’s largest infrastructure conglomerates and its biggest junk-bond borrower, just persuaded its bondholders to let it delay all principal and interest payments until June 30th.
Who holds those bonds? Names you recognize: Cerberus Capital Management, Davidson Kempner, Varde Partners — all major players in private credit (lending done by non-bank funds rather than traditional banks) — and Deutsche Bank, arguably the most globally exposed regulated bank in the private credit universe.
This is not a story about Deutsche Bank going under. It is a story about Ponzi-scheme borrowing — the phase of a debt cycle where struggling companies can no longer service old debt with operating cash flow and must borrow new money just to pay back old investors. When that pattern becomes widespread, it signals that the cycle has crested and is rolling over. This is Stage Two of a private credit downturn. Stage Three is where the real damage lives.
What Stage Three Actually Looks Like
Here is the crucial reframe: in 2008, Lehman Brothers, Bear Stearns, AIG, and Wachovia were symptoms, not causes. Nobody remembers which specific banks collapsed first in the Great Depression either. What history remembers — and what actually did the lasting damage — was the credit crunch those failures signaled was already underway.
A credit crunch is not just “banks being cautious.” It is a sustained, economy-wide withdrawal of credit that chokes off the lifeblood of a modern, specialized, globalized economy. Companies can’t borrow to make payroll. Small businesses can’t get working capital. The damage cascades into jobs and incomes — always hitting ordinary workers hardest, a point even John Maynard Keynes got right.
The Bank of England’s Sarah Breeden said it plainly at a recent Financial Times conference: “We shouldn’t be in a situation where this brings down the banking system, but it might cause a private credit crunch in the way we had a banking credit crunch.” A senior central bank regulator is now publicly warning about the knock-on impact to the real economy. That is not nothing.
PIK and the Erosion of Trust
One of the most corrosive features of the current cycle is the explosion of PIK loans (Payment in Kind — loans where the borrower pays interest not in cash but by adding more debt to the balance, kicking the cash payment down the road). PIK was originally a narrow tool to keep a struggling-but-viable borrower alive through a rough patch. It has become a way to hide garbage lending.
Investor Jeffrey Gundlach recently called out asset manager TCW for continuing to value roughly $56 million of Red Lobster debt at full face value inside a BDC (Business Development Company — a type of publicly regulated fund that lends to private businesses) while simultaneously writing down its equity stake in the same restaurant chain by 98%. The debt has grown larger over time — not because the business is growing, but because interest is accruing via PIK rather than being paid in cash. The marks on the loan suggest TCW believes Red Lobster can still repay in full. The equity write-down suggests the opposite.
Private credit proponents call this an extreme outlier. Critics point out that PIK usage has become endemic across the industry, obscuring how much stress is already present. The deeper problem is not the individual loss — it is the mistrust the opacity creates. Good information builds trust. When information consistently shows something different from stated valuations, trust collapses. And when trust collapses, money stops flowing. That is deflation in its most practical sense.
What the Repo Market Is Already Signaling
This breakdown in trust does not stay inside the private credit industry. It ripples outward — and the early warning system lives in the repo market (short-term loans where one party sells a Treasury security and agrees to buy it back the next day, used by banks and dealers to fund themselves overnight).
Traders are currently placing record-volume bets on a spread between SOFR (Secured Overnight Financing Rate — essentially the average cost of overnight repo loans collateralized by US Treasuries) and the Fed Funds rate (the rate at which banks lend reserves to each other overnight). The bet: that SOFR will spike significantly above Fed Funds by summer, just as it did repeatedly last autumn.
When repo rates spike unexpectedly, it signals that dealers — the large financial institutions that act as intermediaries in the Treasury and credit markets — are pulling back their balance sheet capacity (the willingness and ability to hold assets and take on risk). They become risk-averse. Collateral stops flowing freely. Money stops flowing freely. That is the transmission mechanism from a private credit bust to a systemic credit crunch.
Adding to this signal: Treasury bills (short-term US government debt) are currently priced richly relative to pure investment logic, and primary dealers (the elite banks authorized to trade directly with the Federal Reserve) are hoarding unusually large inventories of both bills and longer-dated bonds. In the eurodollar system (the vast offshore network of US-dollar-denominated credit created by global banks outside the US), these are the kinds of signals that precede a withdrawal of dollar liquidity from the global economy.
The Real Risk: A Permanent Scar, Not a Big Headline
Here is the darkest version of this story, and it is worth sitting with. The private credit boom of 2021–2023 arguably saved the US from a full recession after the regional banking crisis of 2023. Shadow banks kept lending when regulated banks retrenched. Europe, which had less of this private credit cushion, fared worse.
If that cushion now deflates into a credit crunch, the US loses the buffer it leaned on last time. A simultaneous energy price shock — historically one of the most reliable recession triggers — makes the timing especially uncomfortable.
The term economists use for what we are really trying to avoid is a unit root: a permanent, structural shift downward in economic output that does not self-correct, as opposed to a normal recession that rebounds. The post-2008 “silent depression” — years of below-trend growth, stagnant wages, and anemic hiring — was a unit root event. Private credit itself was born from that wreckage, as shadow banks filled the void left by a banking system too scarred to lend normally.
A private credit bust that causes its own unit root would be doubly cruel: the solution to 2008’s permanent crunch would have generated its own permanent crunch, leaving the real economy without another recovery engine.
Conclusion: Follow the Money Flow, Not the Failures
The eurodollar system runs on trust and the free flow of collateral and credit around the globe. When that flow seizes — whether because of Lehman Brothers in 2008 or because of PIK-laden private credit funds in 2025 — the damage is the same. Ordinary workers bear the cost in lost jobs and stagnant wages.
Watching for Deutsche Bank to become “the next Lehman” misses the point entirely. Watch repo rates. Watch T-bill valuations. Watch whether private credit funds start supplying honest information or keep hiding stress behind mark-to-myth accounting. Those are the signals that tell you whether Stage Two tips into Stage Three — and whether the global monetary system is about to get another scar it may not heal from for a decade.
Leave a Reply